In an accusatory tone of voice, the words come out loudly: “And you call yourself a Christian!” Those words are spoken harshly and with great judgment toward someone who says they are a Christian. The accuser can be either a Christian themselves, or they can be, and very often are, people who are not Christians, including atheists. The words, “And you call yourself a Christian,” are an indictment about the conduct of a Christian. The words are intended to do two things. First, the words are intended to call attention to some behavior that is, or appears to be, grossly inconsistent with the character of Jesus Christ. The first intent is to show that someone has failed to meet the high standards of imitating Christ that they take upon themselves when they say, “I am a Christian.” Second, the words are intended to shame someone into changing their position on a matter or altering their behavior. To say to someone, “And you call yourself a Christian,” is a call to action, immediate action, to change and reclaim the higher ground of Christianity. When the charge is properly laid, they are bitter words for the Christian to hear because they reflect a disappointing witness of Christ to the world. When improperly laid, those words are a sign of ignorance by the accuser about the person of Jesus Christ.
I want to pick up with the last thought regarding accusations expressed in ignorance about the person of Jesus Christ. Ignorance about Jesus has existed since his birth. When the announcement of Jesus’ birth was received by the religious leaders of Israel and the king, King Herod, there appears to have been no excitement among the religious leaders and only murderous rage among the king. Throughout Jesus’ public ministry, the religious leaders accused Jesus of being of Satan. In the end, to get the Romans to execute Jesus, the religious leaders falsely accused Jesus of being a traitor to their one and only king, Caesar. After the early church began to take hold across the Roman Empire, accusations were made against Christians for engaging in bizarre and devilish behaviors. Early Christians were accused by Romans and pagans of cannibalism (including eating babies) and related crimes like infanticide, often alongside incest. These accusations arose from the misunderstanding of the words used in the Lord’s Supper and from calling each other brother and sister. People have been and remain suspicious of Christ and Christians.
The Apostle Peter understood pagans' misunderstanding of Christians, and he wanted to address that matter to Christians undergoing persecution for their faith. Peter’s approach was to begin with a simple command. Peter wrote, “He [Jesus] who called you is holy, you also be holy in all your conduct” (1 Peter 1:15 ESV). Peter’s approach toward understanding proper Christian behavior was to start with the character of Christ, “He is holy.” The meaning of the original word here for holy is that of the highest moral standing, meaning to be sinless, pure, and upright. Jesus was forthright in his behavior, never wavering in the purity of his motives or uprightness, never deceiving anyone. He was without sin. Peter said, therefore, that as Christians, followers of Jesus, we must be holy in all we do. They must be pure and upright in their behavior so they can reflect Jesus' virtues and stand in stark contrast to the way of the world. This contrast is essential because Christ represents light and the world darkness. Peter observed that Christians were called that they “may proclaim the excellencies of him who called you out of darkness into his marvelous light” (1 Peter 2:9b). To understand the significance of Christ, Christians must reflect his light.
Peter outlined specific behaviors that Christians must and must not engage in to show forth the light of Christ and represent holy conduct to a hostile culture. We discussed some of these behaviors last week when we prepared our minds for action. Peter said:
- “Put away all malice and all deceit and hypocrisy and envy and all slander” (1 Peter 2:1). These five behaviors are associated primarily with verbal conduct. The ancient world was verbal. Traditions were handed down by word of mouth, making what you said a reflection of who you were. In three years of public ministry, we have no evidence that Jesus ever wrote a letter. Everything was verbal. Jesus told his followers, “37 Let what you say be simply ‘Yes’ or ‘No’; anything more than this comes from evil” (Matthew 5:37). One’s spoken word meant everything and, therefore, deceit, hypocritical language, and slander were witness-killing behaviors, and they still are.
- “16Live as people who are free, not using your freedom as a cover-up for evil, but living as servants of God. Honor everyone. Love the brotherhood. Fear God. Honor the emperor” (1 Peter 2:16). Peter’s charge was to be free of worldly concerns but not to misuse that freedom by being arrogant. Instead, from that position of freedom, show respect to everyone from the common person to the emperor, even if that same emperor was engaged in persecuting Christians. Peter explained why. He said, “12Keep your conduct among the Gentiles honorable, so that when they speak against you as evildoers, they may see your good deeds and glorify God on the day of visitation” (1 Peter 2:12). Peter said similarly, “16Having a good conscience so that, when you are slandered, those who revile your good behavior in Christ may be put to shame” (1 Peter 3:16). And again, Peter said, “3For the time that is past suffices for doing what the Gentiles want to do, living in sensuality, passions, drunkenness, orgies, drinking parties, and lawless idolatry. 4With respect to this they are surprised when you do not join them in the same flood of debauchery, and they malign you; 5but they will give account to him who is ready to judge the living and the dead” (1 Peter 4:3-5). Peter challenged the Christians to be free but to live honorably toward everyone so that when Jesus returns, the pagans will have no excuse for failing to give God the glory because they witnessed God’s character in the people who followed Christ.
Peter’s message urging Christians to be holy in all their conduct was part of Christ's essential witness to the world. Holiness was evidence of the Holy Spirit’s presence within them and a true followship of Christ.
Some hundred years or so later, a man named Diognetus wanted to know about Christians. A friend wrote him to explain who the Christians were and said in part, “The distinction between Christians and other men does not lie in country or language or customs. They follow local customs in clothing, food, and in the rest of life, and yet they exhibit the wonderfully paradoxical nature of their own citizenship. They live in their own countries but as if they were resident aliens. They share all things as citizens and yet endure all things as if they were an underclass. Every foreign country is their homeland and every homeland a foreign country. They marry like everyone else and have children, but they do not abort their young. They keep a common table but not a common bed. They live in the world but not in a worldly way. They enjoy a full life on earth, but their citizenship is in heaven. They obey the appointed laws, but they surpass the laws in their own lifestyle. They love everyone and are universally derided. They are unknown and roundly criticized. They are put to death and gain life. They are poor but make many rich. They lack all things and yet have all things in abundance. They are dishonored and are glorified in their dishonor. They are abused, and they call down blessings in return. When they are beaten up, they rejoice as men who are given a new life. In short, what the soul is in the body, that the Christians are in the world; the soul lives in the body but is not confined by the body, and the Christians live in the world but are not confined by the world. God has appointed them to this great calling, and it would be wrong for them to decline it.” This ancient letter showed that Peter’s words had taken root, and Christians focused their attention on living in a holy manner even when derided, abused, dishonored, and even put to death. They were willing to have someone ask them, “You call yourself a Christian?” and reply, emphatically, “Yes.”
This posture of being holy in a hostile world, as Peter painted it, was essential to the life of a Christian. Being holy reflected the best possible way of living for someone freed from worldly concerns. And Peter said this for this important second reason. Peter said, “In your hearts honor Christ the Lord as holy, always prepared to make a defense to anyone who asks you for the reason for the hope that is in you; yet do it with gentleness and respect” (1 Peter 3:15). The call to be holy included with it the call to share testimony for being so respectful and positive in the face of hostility.
The questions for us today then are three. First, “Am I free of worldly concerns because I have placed my hope in Christ?” Second, “If I am free of worldly concerns, am I living in a holy way?” Third, “If I am free of worldly concerns and living in a holy way, am I prepared and willingly giving a defense for the hope that I have?” Let’s take these questions in order.
Am I free of worldly concerns because I have placed my hope in Christ? What are worldly concerns? There are some obvious things we can consider as worldly concerns, such as wealth and possessions. Worldly people are preoccupied with acquiring more of both, or at least more than their next-door neighbor or more than that member of your extended family who always brags about their income and stuff. The pursuit of wealth and possessions necessarily takes us away from our pursuit of being holy. But there are other, more subtle ways of being tied down, constrained, by worldly concerns. I think one of those concerns is to be accepted by others, especially by people around the world. As humans, we like to be accepted by others. Standing alone or being mocked can be difficult. This is where we differ quite a bit from Peter’s audience. Because Peter’s audience was Christians, they were automatically excluded from the world's acceptance. We, however, especially in this country, are not automatically excluded from being accepted by the world because we are Christian. However, there is great pressure on Christians to bend their ways to gain increasing acceptance. As we have been studying the Book of Revelation, we have seen time and again that Jesus’ message to the seven churches focused on their slow slide into the integration of non-Christian beliefs and behaviors. Doing so is the natural slippery slope all Christians face: slowly and in small ways incorporating worldly concerns into our lives, which necessarily forces our attention away from being holy, away from being a light. And many of those subtle changes in our lives come about because we want to be accepted or not be known as Christians, to avoid any difficulties that the label might bring upon us. Regardless of the reason, when we slide toward worldly concerns, we give up our freedom.
The remedy for this slide, provided by Jesus in the Book of Revelation, is to remember what you have received from Him, salvation; repent, that is, turn back to Christ; and returnto doing the things you first did when freed from the world and your hope was in the eternal.
One of the imperatives when participating in the Lord’s Supper is for Christians to examine themselves before taking the elements. And so, we should examine our lives to see whether we have become entangled in worldly concerns and sacrificed our freedom in Christ. If we have, then remember, repent, and return, and be free again from worldly concerns. We must be free of worldly concerns if we are to take the next step.
That second step, of course, is for our conduct from a posture of freedom to be holy. To be moved toward holy conduct is, of course, evidence of the Holy Spirit moving us. To have that movement in our life, we must continually invite the Holy Spirit to guide our behavior. Are we speaking words that are encouraging? Is it a conscious effort on our part to ask, Is what I am doing holy conduct? Would someone seeing what I am doing say to me, “And you call yourself a Christian!” Be holy by following Jesus’ example, for He is holy.
Our final step is to be the light to others and be willing to share why you are the way you are. When someone says, “How do you do it? How do you remain upbeat even in tough times? Why are you kind even when others are nasty?” Tell them. It is not me. It is Christ living within me. Tell them what Peter told the exiles, “6 Humble yourselves, therefore, under the mighty hand of God so that at the proper time he may exalt you, 7casting all your anxieties on him, because he cares for you” (1 Peter 5:6-7). You can make your answer shorter. “How do you do it?” “Christ enables me to live this way because he cares for me, and he will care for you as well.” You can then say humbly but with a measure of assurance, “And yes, I call myself a Christian!” Amen and Amen.