I want to welcome you here today for a one-of-a-kind experience. Today, we will experience something that has not happened before and will never happen again. You might be saying, “Oh, what is about to happen?” I say this moment is a unique experience that has never happened before and will never happen again because this group of people has never met in this place at this time to sing these hymns, offer these prayers, hear this passage of scripture, and hear this sermon. This is a unique moment in history, and it will never be repeated. Each one of us came here with whatever had happened in the past week, with whatever worries we had on our minds, whatever joys we were thinking about, whatever hopes we had, and that mixture of thought will not be repeated – ever. Please take that truth in for a moment. I want you to have that small sense of history that will not be repeated, because we are about to see a larger sense of history that will not be repeated.
Now, you might be thinking, what you say, Pastor, is true, but we have been here many times before doing something similar. That is true. But I want to invite us to think for a moment about unrepeated and unreplicated history. Because our scripture today is all about an unprecedented moment in history, it involved 13 men, divided into groups of eight and three, and two men who stood alone and separate from one another. The men knew each other very well. They had just eaten a meal together and sung a hymn of praise to God. It was for all but one man a time for contemplation and prayer.
Mark, the gospel writer, wrote, “32 They [Jesus and eleven of his disciples] went to a place called Gethsemane, and Jesus said to his disciples, ‘Sit here and pray” (Mark 14:32). Jesus’ disciples here referred to the Twelve men He had called to be his apostles, his ambassadors. The disciples Jesus spoke to in the moment were Peter, Andrew, James, John, Philip, Bartholomew, Thomas, Matthew, James, son of Alphaeus, Thaddeus, and Simon. One man, Judas Iscariot, was missing from the group. He had left after the meal and before the hymn. Judas would thus stand alone and separate from all others.
For the disciples, Jesus had one request. It was that they would pray. What was said in prayer, we do not know. Who led the prayers, we do not know.
Mark said that Jesus then, “33 Took Peter, James, and John along with him, and he began to be deeply distressed and troubled” (Mark 14:33). We see here that Jesus had separated the disciples. He left eight disciples to remain seated and pray. He selected three of his inner circle of disciples, Peter, James, and John, to come with him. Jesus left Andrew, the fourth of the inner disciples, to stay with the others and pray. Mark then said that Jesus began to be deeply distressed and troubled.
Something had changed in Jesus’ demeanor. Jesus had looked forward to the Passover meal with his disciples. He had celebrated with them and shared his desire that they remember him through the bread and wine. He had prayed for them and assured them that he loved them beyond measure. They had sung hymns and were engaged in prayer. Jesus was wholly involved in a night of worship. But now with three disciples from his inner circle, something had changed in Jesus’ demeanor. Jesus appeared upset, fearful even. Fear is never about the present; it is always about the future. Did you know that? We are only afraid of something that has not yet happened. We do not fear history. Something about what was coming made Jesus appear fearful: moreover, whatever was coming that made Jesus appear fearful also made his spirit, perhaps his voice and body posture, appear heavy-laden, as if the weight of the world rested on his shoulders. Jesus said to his three companions, ”34 ‘My soul is overwhelmed with sorrow to the point of death,’ he said to them. ‘Stay here and keep watch’” (Mark 14:34).
Jesus offered no further clues as to what was overwhelming him, and it does not appear that the disciples asked. Soul here means Jesus’ innermost being, his heart, if you will, was troubled even unto death. Sorrow, grief, was upon Jesus’ soul, like the experience of a loved one's death, such that dying yourself would be preferred to living without them. Jesus had never shown such emotions as this before. Jesus asked his inner circle to stay alert and watch over Him. For what to be alert to, Jesus did not say.
Mark wrote, “35 Going a little farther, he [Jesus] fell to the ground and prayed that if possible the hour might pass from him. 36 ‘Abba, Father,’ he said, ‘everything is possible for you. Take this cup from me. Yet not what I will, but what you will” (Mark 14:35-36). The scene here is troublesome for us to visualize. Jesus, who always seems so confident and assured as the Son of God, now appeared physically weakened, falling to the ground, was overwhelmed with sorrow, and prayed as a child might to seek relief from their father. In doing so, Jesus made a simple five-word prayer, “Take this cup from me.”
What do we make of this situation? Many commentaries and many pastors have offered sermons that this scene shows Jesus’ human side as Jesus contemplated the physical assault that was coming upon him with the crucifixion. They conclude that Jesus wanted the Father to find another way that did not require him to suffer the cross. They conclude that since Jesus was crucified, the Father’s answer to the prayer “Take this cup from me” was “No.” We will have to consider those thoughts in a moment.
As the scene in the garden continued to unfold, Mark wrote, “37 Then he [Jesus] returned to his disciples and found them sleeping. ‘Simon,” he said to Peter, ‘are you asleep? Couldn’t you keep watch for one hour? 38 Watch and pray so that you will not fall into temptation. The spirit is willing, but the flesh is weak” (Mark 14:37-38). We learn here two things. First, Jesus’ simple prayer, “Take this cup from me,” was a prayer of one hour. Did Jesus repeat those words again and again? I do not think so. Jesus had already cautioned his disciples not to pray, repeating the same thing until they were babbling. I think Jesus prayed, “Take this cup from me,” and used his time in prayer to remain quietly within the Father’s will. It would be time with the Father that would quell Jesus’ distress, not by repeating the same words. Second, we learn that the inner group of three disciples had fallen asleep. They did not stay alert and keep watch. Jesus changed his instructions to them, telling them this time, “Watch and pray,” so that they would not be tempted by sleep.
Having set his disciples on a new path, Mark said, “ 39 Once more, he [Jesus] went away and prayed the same thing [“Take this cup from me”]. 40 When he [Jesus] came back, he again found them [the three disciples] sleeping, because their eyes were heavy. They did not know what to say to him. For a second time, Jesus entered a period of prayer with the Father, “Take this cup from me.” For a second time, Jesus lay in the quiet of the garden to receive the Father's comfort and reassurance. For a second time, Jesus’ disciples succumbed to sleep.
Although unstated, Jesus returned to the quiet of the garden and prayed again, “Take this cup from me.” For the third time, Jesus lay in the quiet of the Father’s comforting presence. Having spent time with the Father, Mark wrote, “41 Returning the third time, he [Jesus] said to them [the disciples], 'Are you still sleeping and resting? Enough! The hour has come. Look, the Son of Man is delivered into the hands of sinners. 42 Rise! Let us go! Here comes my betrayer!’” (Mark 14:41-42). For a third time, the disciples were found asleep.
But one of the things we find is that Jesus no longer appeared sorrowful unto death. Jesus no longer appeared overwhelmed with grief. In fact, Jesus sounded extremely confident, saying, “Rise! Let us go! Here comes my betrayer!” Jesus did not mean, “Let’s run away!” Instead, with confidence, Jesus was saying, “Let’s go and greet my betrayer.” A transformation had happened with that garden prayer, “Take this cup from me,” in which Jesus moved from sorrow unto death to confidence, moving toward his betrayer. We must then choose which answer, “Yes” or “No”, is the more likely one to Jesus ' prayer, “Take this cup from me.” What answer to Jesus’ prayer would account for this transformation: “No, I will not take the cup” or “Yes, I will take the cup”? Would we be more encouraged by God if he says “No” or would we be more encouraged by God if he said, “Yes?” And if Jesus were more encouraged by a “Yes” answer than a “No” answer, and he was still crucified and knew that was going to happen, then we would have to conclude the “cup” Jesus wanted removed from him was not the physical crucifixion. If that was so, then what did Jesus mean when he prayed, “Take this cup from me”?
When we want to consider what Jesus said and why he said it, our go-to place must be the Hebrew Scriptures, our Old Testament. Why is that? Because Jesus said, “17 “Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them” (Matthew 5:17). Jesus came to live out the Hebrew Scriptures in a perfect manner. What, then, is the cup of the Hebrew scriptures that Jesus may have asked to pass from him? We look to the prophet Isaiah, who wrote, “
17 Awake, awake! Rise up, Jerusalem, you who have drunk from the hand of the Lord the cup of his wrath, you who have drained to its dregs the goblet that makes people stagger” (Isaiah 51:17). In this context, the cup was not the physical crucifixion; the cup was the wrath of God upon the sinner. The crucifixion that Christ was about to face, as awful as it would be, was so much less than the wrath of God upon the sinner, especially the one who would take upon himself the sins of the world. Physical pain would end with Jesus’ death, but God’s wrath could be eternal. So, Jesus prayed, “ 36 ‘Abba, Father, everything is possible for you. Take this cup from me. Yet not what I will, but what you will” (Mark 14:36). “Everything is possible for God. Take this cup [of wrath] from me [quickly], as I go forth confidently in your will.” Take the cup from me. Take the cup from me.
What was God’s answer to Jesus’ prayer? Rather than “No” as many assume, believing Jesus was asking to avoid the cross, scripture better supports that God said, “Yes,” to having the cup of wrath pass from Jesus. Where is the support for that beyond Jesus’ confidence after prayer? Let’s consider the Hebrew scriptures again.
- Isaiah 51 says, “21 Therefore hear this, you afflicted one, made drunk, but not with wine. 22 This is what your Sovereign Lord says, your God, who defends his people: “See, I have taken out of your hand, the cup that made you stagger; from that cup, the goblet of my wrath, you will never drink again. 23 I will put it into the hands of your tormentors, who said to you, ‘Fall prostrate that we may walk on you.’ And you made your back like the ground, like a street to be walked on.” (Isaiah 51:21-23). God promised in the Old Testament to remove the cup of wrath from his faithful servant.
- Isaiah 53 says, “10 Yet it was the Lord’s will to crush him and cause him to suffer, and though the Lord makes his life an offering for sin, he will see his offspring and prolong his days, and the will of the Lord will prosper in his hand. 11 After he has suffered, he will see the light of life and be satisfied? (Isaiah 53:10-11a). The will of the Lord was that he would suffer and then the suffering would be removed, and he would be restored to life.
- Psalm 22 says, “24 For he has not despised or scorned the suffering of the afflicted one; he has not hidden his face from him but has listened to his cry for help” (Psalm 22:24). God did not forsake Jesus’ prayer; God honored it.
What then do we make of Jesus’ scene in the garden, a scene that occurred only one time in history and will never happen again? What we see is Jesus crying out in prayer that the cup of the wrath of God upon him, taking the sins of the world, would pass from him quickly. That Jesus’ standing with God would be restored fully and completely, even though He was taking upon Himself the sins of the world. God said, “Yes, I will take away the cup of my wrath, and I will give it to your tormentors.” Even at that, Jesus, supremely the Savior, prayed to his Father for his tormentors, “Father, forgive them for they do not know what they are doing” (Luke 23:34).
What then do we take away from this scene? I think there are two things. First, when it comes to prayer, we are probably more like Jesus disciples than Jesus. When asked to pray, we do, but only for a little while; then we tire and sleep. Our spirit may be willing, but our flesh is weak. What is the remedy? Jesus told his disciples, " Pray for strength against temptation. Temptation is our downfall. Temptation to sleep when we could be with God consumes many. Temptation to miss being in worship for other activities of life abounds. The temptation to sin outright is always with us. Jesus remedy for a life spent knowing God’s will begins “38 Watch and pray so that you will not fall into temptation. The spirit is willing, but the flesh is weak.” Honestly, now, how many of us pray for such strength?
Secondly, Jesus prayed, “Take this cup from me,” and following the prophecies of the Old Testament, the cup of God’s wrath was removed. But here is the thing. Jesus held the cup of God’s wrath. Not only that, but Jesus drank from the cup all the way to the dregs, the sediment in the bottom of the cup. Because Jesus did so, you and I do not need to drink from the cup of God’s wrath. When we accept Jesus as Lord and Savior, it is because we have said to Jesus, “Take this cup from me.” In that short, five-word prayer, Jesus repeats back the answer He received from His Father in response to that prayer, “Yes, I will take the cup from you.” Have you prayed Jesus’ prayer? You do not need to wait for another time in history to do that. Make history today and pray, “Take this cup from me.” Amen and Amen.